A CLOSER LOOK AT THE SHOP
Fruit-flavored names offer a simple starting point for comparing these three products. Fresh Strawberry and Blueberry Splash are Headliner gel options, while Encore Wild Cherry uses a cream format.
If flavor is part of your preference, compare it alongside format, ingredients and stated size. That keeps the choice grounded in the complete product rather than the flavor name alone.
Find the details that fit your preferences

Strawberry-labeled gel option
Headliner - Fresh Strawberry
Headliner Fresh Strawberry is a flavored gel in the intimate product range. Its strawberry label distinguishes it from Blueberry Splash, while the gel format separates both Headliner options from the cherry-labeled cream included in this comparison.
View in the shop
Blueberry-labeled gel option
Headliner - Blueberry Splash
Headliner Blueberry Splash is the blueberry-labeled flavored gel option alongside Fresh Strawberry. The flavor name distinguishes the two gel listings, while both share a product format that differs from Encore Wild Cherry’s separately listed cream.
View in the shop
Cherry-labeled cream with stated ingredients
Encore - Wild Cherry Prolonging Cream - 2 fl oz
Encore Wild Cherry is a 2 fl oz cream listing glycerin, menthol, flavoring and Red 40. Its cream format and stated ingredient details distinguish it from the Headliner gels, offering a separate combination of product format and flavor label.
View in the shopHow to choose your own combination
Fresh Strawberry and Blueberry Splash identify two Headliner gel flavor options. Encore lists a 2 fl oz cream with glycerin, menthol, flavoring and Red 40. Flavor labels distinguish the two gels, while format, stated size and named ingredients separate the cream from that pair.
Three details to check before you choose
- Compare gel and cream formats separately.
- Use the complete current ingredient list when checking a formula.
- Follow the current package directions rather than inferring use from flavor names.